Cafe Castello Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Cafe Castello, a charming family-owned gem nestled in Bellport, NY. Here, the warmth of Italian hospitality meets a menu bursting with flavor and authenticity. Diners consistently rave about the incredible pizza, boasting unique options like Chicken Parmesan Pizza, alongside delightful sides such as Garlic Knots.
Beyond pizza, the culinary offerings include beloved classics like Rigatoni alla Vodka, Shrimp Fra Diavolo, and hearty Chicken Parmesan sandwiches, ensuring there's something for everyone. Gluten-free options abound, making Cafe Castello a family-friendly choice.
Owner Nick exemplifies customer care, making each guest feel welcomed and valued. Whether it’s for a quick bite or a celebratory meal, patrons leave with full bellies and smiles. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for gatherings or casual dining. Experience the culinary delights of Cafe Castello, where every dish is crafted with love and passion.
Counter
Pizza
Pizza Specialties
Stuffed Pizza
Drinks
Saturday Music
Sides
Appetizers
Lunch Menu
Soups & Salads
Hot Hero
Cold Hero
Paninis
Pasta
Specials
Entrees
Chicken
Veal
Seafood
Desserts
Pastries
Catering
Special Catering Packages
Pasta Packages
Cheeses
Miscellaneous
Counter
Regular Slice
US$2.52
Reg Slice W/1 Topping
US$3.00
Sicilian Slice
US$3.00
Sicilian Slice W/ 1 Topping
US$3.00
Grandma Slice
US$4.59
Stuffed Meat Slice
US$6.50
Chicken Parm Slice
US$4.59
Spinach Slice
US$4.59
White Slice
US$4.59
Lasagna Slice
US$4.59
Veggie Slice
US$4.59
Buffalo Chicken Slice
US$4.59
CBR Slice
US$4.59
Rustica Slice
US$4.59
Garlic Knots
US$0.50
6 Garlic Knots
US$3.00
Garlic Sticks
US$3.00
Large Round Cheese
US$16.00
Lg. Round Pizza W/ Everything
US$32.00
Small Cheese
US$14.00
Gluten Free Pizza
US$16.00
Sicilian Pizza
US$20.00
Sicilian W/ Everything
US$35.00
Pinwheel
US$5.00
Chicken Roll
US$6.50
Calzone
US$6.43
Sausage Roll
US$6.50
Eggplant Roll
US$6.50
Pepperoni Roll
US$6.50
Pizza
Pizza Specialties
White Pizza
US$27.00
Broccoli Pizza
US$27.00
Lasagna Pizza
US$27.00
Chicken Parm Pizza
US$26.00
Pizza Garden & Sea
US$30.00
Eggplant Pizza
US$25.00
Zucchini & Onions
US$24.00
Grandma
US$24.00
Buffalo Chicken
US$30.00
Margherita
US$24.00
Stuffed Veggies
US$27.00
Stuffed Meat
US$35.00
Stuffed Shrimp & Broccoli
US$35.00
Stuffed Pizza & Broccoli
US$27.00
Stuffed Pizza
Drinks
Soda
US$3.00
Italian Soda
US$3.80
Bottled Water
US$2.00
Wine Glass
US$9.00
Beer
US$6.25
Coffee/Tea
US$2.32
Cappucino
US$4.08
Espresso
US$3.25
Hot Chocolate
US$3.75
Sparkling Water
US$3.50
1 Liter Sparkling Water
US$8.00
Bottled Water
US$2.00
Soda
US$3.00
Beer
US$6.25
Wine Glass
US$9.00
Cannoli
US$3.75
Cheesecake
US$5.50
Saturday Music
Sides
Side Meatball
US$6.00
Side Sausage
US$6.00
Side Fries
US$5.50
Baked Clams
US$13.00
Clams Marinara
US$13.00
Mussels Marinara Appetizer
US$12.00
Fried Calamari
US$17.00
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato
US$15.00
Broccoli Di Rabe
US$15.00
Sauteed Spinach
US$13.00
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
US$9.00
Fresh Mozzarella
US$10.00
Fried Zucchini
US$8.00
Pizza Dough
US$5.00
Pint Of Marinara Sauce
US$9.00
Pint Of Vodka Sauce
US$12.00
Sauteed Broccoli
US$13.00
Appetizers
Lunch Menu
Grilled Chicken & Veggies
US$15.00
Grilled Chicken & Spinach
US$15.00
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli
US$15.00
Chicken Strips And Fries
US$10.00
Italian Salad
US$12.00
Cold Antipasto For Two
US$17.00
Minestrone Soup
US$7.00
Pasta E Fagioli
US$7.00
Lentil
US$7.00
Chicken Noodle
US$7.00
Butternut Squash
US$7.00
Cheese Tortellini
US$7.00
Cauliflower
US$7.00
Wedding
US$7.00
Lemon Chicken Salad
US$11.00
Caesar Salad
US$8.00
Caesar Salad W/ Chicken
US$13.00
Soups & Salads
Hot Hero
Meatball Hero
US$12.00
Sausage Hero
US$12.00
Chicken Cutlet Hero
US$14.00
Veal Parm Hero
US$14.00
Sausage, Peppers & Onion Hero
US$13.00
Fried Shrimp W/Marinara Sauce Hero
US$17.00
Eggplant Hero
US$12.00
Garlic Bread Hero
US$3.50
Salami & Provolone Hero Cold
US$14.00
Submarine Hero Cold
US$14.00
Chicken Cutlet Hero Cold
US$15.00
Cold Hero
Paninis
Prosciutto Pannini
US$8.00
Spinach Pannini
US$8.00
Roasted Pepper Pannini
US$8.00
Veggie Pannini
US$8.00
Tomato & Basil Pannini
US$8.00
Sausage & Pepper Pannini
US$8.00
Buffalo Mozzarella Sun-Dried Tomato And Prosciutto Panini
US$14.00
Turkey Mozzarella Di Buffalo Castelvetrano Olive Panini
US$14.00
Crema Di Parmigiano Mortadella Tomato Pistachio Primosale
US$14.00
Mortadella Burrata Pesto Crema Di Parmigiano Panini
US$14.00
Roasted Pepperoni Mortadella Provola Panini
US$14.00
Prosciutto Salame Burrata Panini
US$14.00
Provola Cotto Crema Di Pistacchio Panini
US$14.00
Arugula Pomodorini Shredded Parmigiano Speck Panini
US$14.00
Prosciutto Mozzarella Crema Di Parmigiano Tomato Panini
US$14.00
Pancetta Salame Burrata Tomato Panini
US$14.00
Rigatoni Al Filetto Di Pomodoro
US$18.95
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
US$18.95
Ravioli Alla Castello
US$18.95
Cappellini Al Pomodoro
US$17.95
Farfalle W/ Broccoli & Zucchini
US$17.95
Fettucine Alfredo
US$18.00
Linguine Carbonara
US$19.55
Penne Rigate Alla Bellini
US$19.55
Trinete Al Pesto
US$17.95
Linguine Alla Primavera
US$19.55
Penne Castello
US$19.55
Manicotti
US$19.95
Cheese Ravioli
US$19.95
Lasagna
US$19.95
Stuffed Shells
US$19.95
Baked Ziti
US$19.95
Rigatoni Bolognese
US$19.95
Linguine W/ Meatballs
US$19.95
Linguine Marinara
US$19.95
Linguine In Tomato Sauce
US$19.95
Gnocchi Bolognese
US$25.00
Fusilli W/ Shrimp
US$26.00
Pacchari Bolognese
US$21.00
Baked Ravioli
US$17.00
Pasta
Specials
Gnocchi Bolognese
US$25.00
Paccheri Bolognese
US$25.00
Lobster Ravioli
US$26.00
Fusili W/Shrimp
US$27.00
Cavatelli Contadina
US$25.00
Cavatelli Cacciatore
US$25.00
Castellos Combo
US$25.00
Castellos Surf & Turf
US$25.00
Eggplant Rollatine
US$23.00
Castellos Special
US$23.00
Eggplant Parmigiana
US$21.00
Sausage & Peppers
US$23.00
Entrees
Chicken
Chicken Parm Dinner
US$22.95
Breast Of Chicken Marsala
US$22.95
Breast Of Chicken Francese
US$22.95
Breast Of Chicken Piccata
US$22.95
Veal Sorrentino
US$28.00
Veal Saltimbocca
US$28.00
Veal Marsala
US$28.00
Veal Alla Castello
US$28.00
Veal Parm Dinner
US$28.00
Veal Francese
US$28.00
Veal
Seafood
Mussels Marinara Dinner
US$26.00
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
US$26.00
Shrimp Francese
US$27.25
Calamari Marinara
US$26.00
Shrimp Alla Castello
US$27.00
Shrimp Marinara
US$27.25
Shrimp Parmigiana
US$25.95
Farfalle Giacomo
US$27.00
Scungilli Marinara
US$33.00
Clams Posillipo
US$28.00
Linguine Alla Frutti De Mare
US$37.00
Linguine W/ White Clam Sauce
US$27.00
Linguine W/Red Clam Sauce
US$27.00
Salmon Tagliatelle
US$28.00
Shrimp Scampi
US$27.25
Seafood Lovers Platters
US$55.00
Shrimp Oreganata
US$23.50
Flounder Oreganata
US$23.50
Gelato
US$5.50
Cheesecake
US$5.50
Gluten Free Freezer
US$8.00
Desserts
Pastries
Sfgohiatelle
US$4.25
Scone
US$3.25
Cookies
US$1.50
Cannoli
US$3.75
Meatballs
Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana
US$0.00
Frutti Di Mare
US$0.00
Chicken Piccata
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Francese
Chicken Contadina
Veal Parmigiana
Baked Stuffed Shells
US$0.00
Penne Alla Filleto Di Pomodoro
US$0.00
Pasta W/ Broccoli & Zucchini
US$0.00
Pasta Alla Giacomo
US$0.00
Pasta Alla Castello
US$0.00
Sausage & Peppers
US$0.00
Salad Catering
US$0.00
Caesar
US$0.00
Antipasto
US$0.00
Baked Clams
US$0.00
Baked Ziti
US$0.00
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmigiana
US$0.00
Eggplant Rollatine
US$0.00
Lasagna
US$0.00
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Rigatoni Bolognese
Baked Ravioli
US$0.00
Mussels Marinara
Catering
Special Catering Packages
Catering #1-20 People
US$342.95
Catering #2-40 People
US$599.95
Catering #3- 80 People
US$1,099.95
Gluten Free Gnocchi
US$15.00
Gluten Free Ravioli
US$15.00
Pasta Packages
Cheeses
Parmesan Wedges
US$22.00
Auriccho
US$14.00
Ricotta Salata
US$10.00
Pecerino Romano 1lb
US$14.00
Fiore Di Sardegna
US$14.00
Primo Sale
US$14.75
Provolone
US$13.00
Salami
US$13.00
Olives
US$6.75
Peppers
US$5.75
Nutella
US$6.50
Olive Spread
US$6.00
Torrone
US$12.00
Pignoli
US$8.00
Tuna
US$7.00
Anchovie
US$5.00
Balsamic Glaze
US$12.00
Soap Small
US$14.00
Soap Large
US$18.00
Olive Oil
US$26.00
Lupini Beans
US$5.75
Panettone
US$21.00